The National and Individual Selfhood
Set within the historic halls of Government Gordon College, The Selfhood of the Nation and the Individual weaves a compelling philosophical dialogue between a seasoned professor and his three perceptive students. Tracing the intellectual journey from the collapse of the Soviet Union and Alexander Dugin’s radical critique of Western modernity to the profound insights of Abdelwahab El-Messiri, the story explores the hidden crisis of mental colonization. Ultimately, it bridges global geopolitics with Allama Iqbal’s timeless philosophy of Khudi, offering a powerful message on spiritual awakening and civilizational revival.
أَعُوذُ بِاللّٰهِ مِنَ الشَّيْطَانِ الرَّجِيمِ
بِسۡمِ ٱللهِ ٱلرَّحۡمَـٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ
In the name of ALLAH, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful
The National and Individual Selfhood
Government Gordon College is a century-and-a-quarter-old educational institution in the city, renowned across the region as a nursery for political consciousness and future leaders. For the teaching and pursuit of history, philosophy, and political science, it has always been a favored hub for both teachers and students. Winter was just beginning to set in, and the sound of footsteps echoed across the marble floor of the college's history block. A political science class was in session, and the discussion revolved around the modern era. Adjusting his glasses with thick books stacked on his desk, Professor Siddiqui was speaking about the changing landscape of Russia and the global order following the fall of the Berlin Wall. Three of his bright students were actively participating in the debate: Zaid, an ardent admirer of history and Iqbal’s philosophy; Kashif, who was accustomed to viewing every event through the lens of modern psychology; and Rafay, a representative of Generation Z, who held an iPad in his hand and evaluated everything from the perspective of the digital world and the future.
Professor Siddiqui drew a line on the chalkboard and broke the silence in the room, saying, "Dear students, in the late 1980s, the last President of the Soviet Union, Mikhail Gorbachev, introduced two major Western-style reforms to save his economy and system: Glasnost (political openness) and Perestroika (economic and administrative restructuring). However, importing these concepts of Western modernity into their system backfired completely. A state that had been considered an invincible superpower for decades hollowed out from within and collapsed like a house of cards. Following the fall of the Berlin Wall and the sudden collapse of the Soviet Union, the West declared that history had reached its end and that liberal democracy was humanity’s final destination. Yet, from the corridors of a defeated Moscow rose a voice that challenged this entire narrative. That voice belonged to the Russian philosopher Alexander Dugin. He raised a new slogan: Russia and the West must rid themselves of modernity! Remember, modernity has seemingly given modern man everything, yet Dugin’s declaration was an outright negation of modernity itself... and just like that, an uproar erupted across the intellectual world!"
Swiping his fingers across his iPad screen, Rafay immediately asked in surprise, "Sir, an uproar was bound to happen! Gorbachev only tried to give people freedom, and modernity has given today’s human beings technology, comforts, and individual liberty. Why would Dugin negate all of this and try to push the world backward?"
Professor Siddiqui smiled, looked toward Kashif, and said, "Look, Rafay, three decades have passed since the Berlin Wall fell and this so-called new world order arrived, yet human problems continue to multiply rather than diminish. That is why Dugin was compelled to say that the problem lies elsewhere! So, what do you think this problem could be? Tell us, Kashif!"
Resting his chin on his hand, Kashif began speaking in detail from a psychological and sociological perspective: "Sir, the very root of Dugin’s philosophy is the claim that all modern political ideologies share a single fatal flaw: the rejection of 'Tradition,' the 'Sacred,' and 'genuine, authentic Christianity.' The sovereign 'individual' that Rafay is referring to—Dugin identifies this liberal myth as the central point of this rebellion. He rejects the notion of total individual autonomy as an 'ideological bluff' and a strict impossibility. Even psychologically speaking, an individual is not a self-contained or independent entity born in a vacuum; rather, it is an artificial product of the modern system. Our values, our desires, our fears, and our worldviews have all been installed into us by society through ideological tools. Dugin’s blunt argument is that liberalism did not discover or liberate a pre-existing free individual; rather, it deliberately induced the 'individual' in order to fragment society and sever human beings from their natural, sacred, and communal roots."
Professor Siddiqui nodded in agreement and, pacing through the classroom, unraveled the philosophical knot further: "Precisely, Kashif! In Dugin’s metaphysical framework—which draws heavily on Christian eschatological imagery—all modern ideologies, whether liberalism, communism, or fascism, are in fact 'horns of the Beast.' This is because they systematically dethrone God and replace the divine order with human-centric constructs."
Stopping near the chalkboard, Professor Siddiqui turned the pages of history and continued, "To trace the origin of this crisis, Dugin points to a profound historical rupture that occurred roughly five hundred years ago in Western Europe. In mainstream historiography, the eras of the Renaissance, the Reformation, and the Age of Exploration are celebrated as the dawn of enlightenment, scientific inquiry, and human emancipation. Dugin completely inverts this narrative. He believes this turning point actually marked the systematic elimination of Christianity from every sphere of human life—not just religion, but physics, cosmology, politics, culture, morality, and metaphysics. By abandoning a sacred, vertical orientation toward the Divine in favor of secular materialism and a 'false theory of progress,' the West brought an end to what Dugin calls the 'normal world' of the Middle Ages, plunging humanity into a long, dark phase of 'apocalyptic preparations.'"
Rafay furrowed his brow in astonishment. "Sir, that sounds like turning logic completely upside down! The West modernized the entire world and ruled over it; how could the West itself fall victim to this crisis?"
"That is Dugin’s most astonishing and profound point, Rafay!" Professor Siddiqui explained enthusiastically. "He inverts postcolonial theory in a remarkable way. Dugin argues that the most powerful and lethal form of imperialism is the 'colonization of the mind,' and that Western modernity colonized the West itself before it ever colonized the rest of the world. The Enlightenment usurped Europe’s historical consciousness, distorted its intellectual heritage, and stole its authentic traditions. Consequently, Dugin asserts that if the West wishes to rediscover its true identity, it must first 'decolonize itself.' And this mental liberation will not come through superficial conspiracy theories, but through rigorous intellectual deconstruction utilizing philosophy, sociology, anthropology, political science, and the history of religions. Ultimately, Dugin prescribes an uncompromising cure: Western civilization must 'roll back its settings' to the era before the Modern Age and embrace a 'new Middle Ages' to save itself from spiritual extinction."
Zaid, who had been quietly taking notes until now, leaned forward and spoke: "Sir, is this the purpose for which Dugin presents his 'Fourth Political Theory'?"
"Yes, Zaid," Professor Siddiqui clarified. "In the twentieth century, three ideologies clashed: liberalism, centered on the 'individual'; communism, centered on 'class'; and fascism, centered on 'race.' Communism—whose end we witnessed in the collapse of the Soviet Union—and fascism both failed because they remained trapped within the confines of materialism. Dugin’s Fourth Political Theory rejects all three and places Heidegger’s concept of Dasein—a living human existence rooted in Tradition and spirituality—at the center of history. In this struggle, he casts his country, Russia, in the role of the biblical Katechon, the force that restrains evil. To him, Russia is not an ordinary nation-state, but the core of the Eurasian civilization."
Hearing this, Rafay immediately posed a critical question: "Sir, it stands to reason to ask: if Dugin’s proposal is fully implemented, what civilizational impact will it have on Russia itself?"
Professor Siddiqui smiled. "A very important question, Rafay! For Russia, it means a complete transformation from a modern, secular state into an ideological and spiritual empire. Internally, it means subordinating individual rights and market economics to collective spiritual goals, demographic renewal, Orthodox traditionalism, and hierarchical authority. Russia would cease measuring its success by Western standards of material wealth or technological consumerism, judging itself instead by its fidelity to spiritual Tradition and geopolitical sovereignty."
Kashif followed up with a second question: "And Sir, what impact will it have on the rest of the world? Will it alter the structure of the global order?"
"Undoubtedly, Kashif!" Professor Siddiqui replied. "For the rest of the world, Dugin’s vision seeks to shatter the unipolar, Western-led global order and replace it with a multipolar world composed of distinct civilizations. In this multipolar framework, Western values—such as liberal democracy, secularism, and universal human rights—would be stripped of their claim to universality and exposed merely as the local, decaying customs of a declining civilization."
Zaid asked a third question out of curiosity: "Sir, does that mean other non-Western civilizations would also get the opportunity to return to their traditional systems?"
"Exactly, Zaid!" the Professor nodded. "Under Dugin’s vision, other major civilizational blocs—such as the Islamic world, China, India, and Latin America—would be encouraged to achieve their own 'mental decolonization' from Western modernity and reclaim their indigenous traditions, religions, and social orders."
A deep silence fell over the hall. The winter sunlight filtered through the windowpanes, casting streaks across the marble floor. Zaid took a deep breath and spoke: "Sir, listening to the fall of the Soviet Union and all of Dugin’s arguments, I realize what a massive lesson lies hidden in this for us Muslims. Just as Gorbachev turned to Western reforms to save his system and the entire state came crashing down, there are segments among us today who believe we can change our destiny by imitating Western modernity. Yet, that is akin to seeking a cure from the very poison that made us sick."
A spark lit up in Professor Siddiqui’s eyes. "Who are you pointing toward, Zaid?"
Zaid answered confidently, "Sir, I am pointing toward the great twenty-first-century Egyptian thinker Abdelwahab El-Messiri and our very own Allama Muhammad Iqbal. El-Messiri devoted twenty years of his life to studying Zionism and modernity, proving that capitalism, globalization, imperialism, and Zionism are all different manifestations of the same materialist paradigm—one that reduces both nature and human beings to mere usable matter. Against the 'fragmented individual' of Western liberalism, El-Messiri articulated the true nature of the human being: that wondrous creature into whom God breathed His spirit and instilled an innate leaning toward religion, art, and morality."
Kashif immediately chimed in, "And psychologically too, when a human being is stripped of their spiritual identity, they become hollow from within. This spiritual vacuum is the root cause of modern humanity's anxiety and alienation."
"Precisely!" Zaid said passionately. "And it was to fill this very spiritual vacuum and rescue Muslims from mental slavery that Allama Iqbal presented his Philosophy of Khudi (the Self). Decades ago, Iqbal foresaw that behind the outward dazzle of Western civilization lay a profound moral darkness. The 'individual' of the West is a slave to consumerism and desires, whereas Iqbal’s Khudi is built through divine love, self-mastery, and relentless action. When an individual’s Khudi awakens, they cease to be a passive subject of circumstances and instead become God’s vicegerent on earth, writing their own destiny—and when the Khudi of individuals awakens, the collective Khudi of the entire nation comes alive."
During this exchange, Professor Siddiqui’s gaze fell upon the rest of the students sitting quietly in the back rows of the hall, passively copying down notes like mere spectators. With a gesture of his hand, the Professor addressed the entire class in a firm yet affectionate tone: "The rest of you should also participate in this class discussion... What is this, carrying a load of books and papers on your backs like beasts of burden without truly learning anything! Remember, superficial information never awakens consciousness. To acquire deep knowledge, you must read books, and to become a responsible individual, read with utmost dedication and focus in pursuit of knowledge so you may expand your intellectual capacity."
A moment of solemnity swept over the classroom, and several students sat up straight. Just then, Rafay closed his iPad, placed it on the desk, and smiled: "That means, Sir, true innovation and the future do not lie in blind imitation of the past or enslavement to the West, but in deep study and discovering ourselves by reconnecting with our spiritual roots."
Professor Siddiqui glanced at his watch; the bell signaling the end of the period had rung. Gathering his books, he looked across the entire class with a deep smile and said, "Indeed! In this intellectual battle between Heaven and Hell, ultimate victory will belong to the nation that liberates its mind from slavery and recognizes the Khudi of both the individual and the nation. I will conclude today’s class with these timeless verses by the Poet of the East, Allama Iqbal, which capture the very essence of our discussion today:
In the hands of individuals lies the destiny of nations,
Every individual is a star of the community’s fate.
And when the individual and the nation discover this secret of their Khudi, Iqbal proclaims:
The hidden secret of the Self is 'There is no god but Allah,'
The Self is the whetstone of the sword—'There is no god but Allah.'
Do not judge your nation by the standards of Western nations,
Distinct in its very composition is the nation of the Hashemite Prophet (peace be upon him).
Today’s class ends here."
As the three students stepped out of the hall, a crisp winter breeze was blowing through the old corridors of Gordon College, yet new lamps of history, civilization, and Khudi had been lit within their minds.